The short answer
● GPT Image 2.6 — Best overall. Leads on prompt adherence and in-image text. Token-priced, no flat per-image rate.
● FLUX 3 Klein — Cheapest serious model at $0.009 per 1K image, and the weights are open.
● Nano Banana 2.1 — Best quality per dollar on a hosted API: $0.0336 per 1K image.
The full comparison
| Tool |
Wins at |
Entry price |
Per 1K image |
Score |
| GPT Image 2.6 |
Everything, generally |
Token-priced API |
$8 / $30 per 1M tokens |
44/50 |
| FLUX 3 |
Photorealism, API economics |
$0.048/img |
$0.048 · Klein $0.009 |
43/50 |
| Nano Banana 2.1 |
Quality per dollar |
$0.0336/img |
$0.0336 |
42/50 |
| Ideogram 4.0 |
Readable text in image |
$15/mo annual |
Credit-based |
41/50 |
| Adobe Firefly |
Commercial safety |
See Adobe plans |
Unlimited on offer |
41/50 |
| Recraft V4.1 |
Vectors, brand systems |
$10/mo annual |
Credit-based |
40/50 |
| Stable Diffusion 3.5 |
Customisation, fine-tunes |
Free self-hosted |
$0.025 to $0.065 |
38/50 |
| Midjourney V8.1 |
Aesthetics, art direction |
$8/mo annual |
~$0.013 |
36/50 |
| QuillBot |
Images inside writing |
Free, 3 a day |
Free |
32/50 |
How we tested, and what the score means
Every tool is scored out of 10 on five criteria, for a total out of 50. The five are output quality, prompt accuracy, text inside images, cost efficiency and commercial safety.
The sections below run in score order, highest first. A high total means a tool is strong across the board — it does not mean it is the right one for your job. Midjourney sits eighth on 36 while scoring 10 out of 10 on output quality and 4 on in-image text, and that split is exactly the point. If you want the best-looking image and nothing else matters, the eighth-placed tool is your answer. Read the breakdown, not just the number.
| Tool |
Quality |
Prompt |
Text |
Cost |
Commercial |
Total |
| GPT Image 2.6 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
6 |
8 |
44 |
| FLUX 3 |
9 |
9 |
8 |
9 |
8 |
43 |
| Nano Banana 2.1 |
9 |
9 |
8 |
9 |
7 |
42 |
| Ideogram 4.0 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
7 |
7 |
41 |
| Adobe Firefly |
8 |
8 |
7 |
8 |
10 |
41 |
| Recraft V4.1 |
8 |
8 |
8 |
8 |
8 |
40 |
| Stable Diffusion 3.5 |
7 |
7 |
6 |
9 |
9 |
38 |
| Midjourney V8.1 |
10 |
7 |
4 |
8 |
7 |
36 |
| QuillBot |
6 |
6 |
5 |
9 |
6 |
32 |
Cost efficiency is scored on published list price at 1K resolution, not on promotional rates. Commercial safety is scored on what the licence actually grants: indemnification scores highest, open weights next, standard platform terms lowest.
Also worth knowing: the aggregators
Some platforms resell several of the models below behind one subscription. They are not ranked here because you are buying access, not a model.
| Platform |
Entry price |
API |
Trial |
| DeeVid sponsored |
$10/mo (Lite, annual) |
No |
200 credits |
| Adobe Firefly |
See Adobe plans |
Yes |
Free tier |
1. GPT Image 2.6 — best overall
Verdict: The most reliable model for briefs with several moving parts, and the one that gets closest to usable text on the first try. You pay for that in pricing you cannot predict per image.
OpenAI now ships four current image variants: gpt-image-2.6-sunburst, gpt-image-2.6-flare, gpt-image-2.5-sunburst and gpt-image-2.5-flare. Plain gpt-image-2 survives only in the batch tier. If you are still calling gpt-image-2 by name, you are on a superseded model.
Pricing. There is no flat per-image rate any more. Sunburst bills $5.00 per million text input tokens, $8.00 per million image input tokens and $30.00 per million output tokens, with cached input at $1.25 and $2.00. Batch halves it. That is good news at volume and bad news for budgeting: cost moves with prompt length and image complexity, so a single detailed brief can cost several times a simple one.
Standout. Markup-guided edits, SVG output and animated GIF output, plus a complexity setting that trades spend against detail. The editing loop is the real reason to pick it — revising an existing image without losing the rest of the frame is where other models fall down.
Limitation. No published per-image price means no clean comparison against FLUX or Nano Banana without running your own prompts and reading the bill.
Best for production pipelines, editing and revision loops, complex multi-element briefs
2. FLUX 3 — best photorealism and best API economics
Verdict: The price-performance winner, and it is not close. Klein gives you frontier-class output at under a cent an image with weights you can run yourself.
Black Forest Labs has moved past FLUX.2. The current line is FLUX 3 Image at $0.041 for 768×768, $0.048 at 1K, $0.07 at 1.5K, $0.10 at 2K and $0.607 at 4K.
The one to actually look at. FLUX 3 Image Klein costs $0.008 at 768×768, $0.009 at 1K, $0.011 at 1.5K, $0.014 at 2K and $0.036 at 4K. It is 5.6 billion parameters, runs on a single consumer GPU, and ships on open weights. At 1K it is roughly a fifth the price of Nano Banana 2.1 and about a seventeenth the price of FLUX 3 at 4K.
Standout. Open weights at that quality level change what you can build. You can fine-tune it, run it offline, and keep generation costs off the API meter entirely.
Limitation. The 4K jump on full FLUX 3 is brutal — $0.607 an image, six times the 2K price. Generate at 2K and upscale unless 4K is contractually required.
Best for product photography at volume, ecommerce assets, architectural renders, any API pipeline
3. Nano Banana 2.1 and Imagen 4 — best quality per dollar on a hosted API
Verdict: The best hosted model you can buy for about three cents an image. No free API tier, whatever you have read elsewhere.
Nano Banana 2.1 (model ID gemini-nano-banana-2.1) landed in October 2026 as an update to Nano Banana 2, which is Gemini 3.1 Flash Image. Above it sits Nano Banana Pro, which is Gemini 3 Pro Image.
Pricing. Nano Banana 2.1 bills $1.50 per million input tokens and $30.00 per million image output tokens, which Google states as $0.0336 per 1K image, $0.0504 per 2K and $0.113 per 4K. Nano Banana Pro runs $0.134 at 1K and 2K and $0.24 at 4K. Imagen 4 is flat-rate: Fast $0.02, Standard $0.04, Ultra $0.06.
Read this before you budget. The free tier is listed as not available for image generation on the paid API. Image models get no free allowance. The only free allowance on that pricing page is 5,000 monthly search-grounding requests, which is a different thing entirely.
Standout. It supports thinking and search grounding, and takes text, image, video and PDF as input with a 131,072-token input window. For generating imagery that has to match a source document, nothing else on this list is close.
Limitation. No caching, no function calling, no structured outputs. It is a generation endpoint, not a building block.
Best for blog and marketing imagery, multi-subject scenes, document-grounded visuals, Google Cloud pipelines
4. Ideogram 4.0 — best for text inside images
Verdict: Still the one to use when the words have to be spelled right. Everything else is a bonus.
Pricing, correctly stated. The headline numbers are annual, not monthly. Plus is $20 a month billed monthly, or $15 a month on $180 billed annually, with 2,400 priority credits. Pro is $60 monthly or $42 a month on $504 annually, with 7,500 priority credits. Team is $30 per user monthly or $20 per user on $240 annually, with 3,600 credits per user and a two-seat minimum. Enterprise is postpaid.
Free tier. Eligible accounts get weekly slow credits after signing in with Google, Apple or Microsoft. Slow credits are unlimited on every paid plan.
Standout. Unlimited character consistency on all paid plans, which matters more than the text rendering for anyone building a series rather than a one-off.
Limitation. Credit-based pricing makes per-image cost opaque. Pro buys the best cost per credit, so the $42 tier is better value than the $15 one if you generate at all seriously.
Best for posters, thumbnails, ad creative, packaging mockups, anything with a headline in it
5. Adobe Firefly — best for commercial safety
Verdict: No longer just Adobe’s own model. Firefly is now a multi-model studio, and the indemnification story is what you are paying for.
The plan lineup is Firefly Pro, Firefly Pro Plus and Firefly Premium, plus credit plans at 4,000, 7,000, 10,000 and 50,000 credits. The Standard tier is gone.
What changed. Firefly now hosts third-party models alongside Adobe’s own: GPT Image 1.5, GPT Image 2, GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst and Flare, Flux Kontext Max and Pro, Flux1.1 pro and ultra, FLUX.2 Pro, FLUX.2 klein 4B, Nano Banana 2, Nano Banana Pro, Runway Gen 4, Topaz Bloom and Topaz Gigapixel. Coverage varies by tier — Pro Plus unlocks Nano Banana 2 at 1K/2K, Premium unlocks Nano Banana Pro at 4K.
The offer worth knowing. Eligible individual plans get unlimited generations on selected models and resolutions for twelve months from the day the plan starts. A plan begun 21 May 2026 runs unlimited through 20 May 2027, after which you return to consuming credits. It applies only on firefly.adobe.com and the Firefly mobile app, not in Photoshop or any other desktop app. Teams and Enterprise are excluded.
Always included, offer or no offer. Unlimited Firefly Image 4, Firefly Image 3, Generative Fill, Generative Erase, Generative Expand, Remove Background and Upscale, on every Firefly and credit plan, during and after the promotional period.
Limitation. Adobe reserves the right to change which models are covered, and to throttle or queue during high demand. Build a client workflow on a partner model and it can be withdrawn from the offer.
Best for agency and client work, brand assets, regulated industries, anything needing indemnification
6. Recraft V4.1 — best for vectors and brand systems
Verdict: The only one here that outputs real vectors and keeps a style locked across a set. Credits that never expire is a genuinely unusual term.
Pricing. Basic is $12 a month billed monthly, or $10 a month on $120 billed annually, for 1,000 credits. Pro scales in four steps: 2,000 credits at $20 monthly or $16 annually, 4,000 at $40 or $32, 8,000 at $80 or $64, and 16,000 at $160 or $128. Annual billing saves up to 20 percent. Teams start at $22 a month.
Standout. Top-up credits never expire and stay usable even after a subscription ends, in packs of 200, 400, 800 and 1,600. Every other credit system on this list burns what you do not use. Commercial usage rights come with every paid plan.
Limitation. Monthly credits still reset monthly — only top-ups roll over. And the vector advantage narrows if you only ever export raster.
Best for icon sets, logo concepts, design systems, anything that has to scale cleanly
7. Stable Diffusion 3.5 — best for customisation
Verdict: Pick it when you need to own the model, not rent it. The hosted prices are now clear enough to plan against.
Pricing, finally specific. Stability bills in credits where one credit is one cent, and gives you 25 free to start. SD 3.5 Large is 6.5 credits, $0.065 an image. Large Turbo is 4 credits, $0.04. Medium is 3.5 credits, $0.035. SD 3.5 Flash, a distilled Medium, is 2.5 credits, $0.025. Stable Image Ultra, built on 3.5 Large, is 8 credits. Stable Image Core is 3. Legacy SDXL 1.0 starts at 0.9.
Standout. Open weights and a fine-tuning ecosystem nothing else here matches. If your use case is a specific style applied thousands of times, training on 3.5 and self-hosting beats every per-image price in this table.
Limitation. Base output quality sits below the frontier models, and at $0.065 the hosted Large endpoint costs more per image than FLUX 3 at 1K. Self-hosting is where the value is.
Best for custom style fine-tuning, anime and niche aesthetics, batch generation, full local control
8. Midjourney V8.1 — best artistic quality
Verdict: Still the best-looking output on the list and still the worst at doing what it is told. A 36 here means specialised, not weak.
Pricing, unchanged. Basic $10 a month or $8 annually, roughly 200 image jobs a month — and since one job returns four images, about 800 images, which works out near $0.013 each. Standard $30 or $24, with 15 hours of fast generation and unlimited relax. Pro $60 or $48, 30 fast hours, stealth mode. Mega $120 or $96, 60 fast hours. Annual billing is 20 percent off across the board. General commercial terms on every tier.
Standout. Stealth mode on Pro and Mega keeps your generations private. Pro and Mega also run 12 simultaneous fast image jobs against Basic and Standard’s three.
Limitation. No API and no free trial, so it cannot sit in an automated pipeline and you cannot evaluate it without paying. In-image text remains its weakest area by a wide margin.
Best for concept art, campaign imagery, mood boards, anything judged on how it looks
9. QuillBot — best if you already write there
Verdict: Convenience, not capability. The free limit is three images a day, which the marketing does not lead with.
Pricing and limits. Free and signed in gets you three images every 24 hours. Premium is $4.17 a month billed annually and raises that to 300 images a month. You must have an account to view or download what you generate.
Standout. No watermark on free output, which several free generators cannot say. If you are already drafting in QuillBot, the image sits one tab away from the text.
Limitation. The underlying model is undisclosed — the page says only a diffusion model fine-tuned for popular styles. Commercial terms are informal: QuillBot says images can be used for professional and personal projects and advises checking your own policies, which is not the same as a licence grant. Do not build client deliverables on it.
Best for existing QuillBot users, blog imagery, students and writers
Sponsored — pricing verified, not scored against the nine above
Sponsored
DeeVid is an AI image-generation platform. Lite is $10 a month billed annually, Pro is $25 and Premium is $119. The trial includes 200 credits. There is no API.
DeeVid is a paid advertiser on AIToolsRecap. It is not part of the ranking, carries no score, and its placement did not affect any verdict above.
Decision framework
- You need the lowest possible cost per image → FLUX 3 Klein at $0.009 per 1K, open weights.
- You need indemnification for client work → Adobe Firefly. Nothing else here offers it.
- The image has readable text in it → Ideogram 4.0 Pro.
- You are revising an image rather than generating one → GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst.
- You need logos, icons or anything that scales → Recraft V4.1.
- You want one specific style, thousands of times → fine-tune Stable Diffusion 3.5 and self-host.
- It just has to look extraordinary → Midjourney V8.1 Standard.
- You generate three images a week inside a doc → QuillBot free.
The workflow stack that professionals actually run
Almost nobody serious runs one model. The common stack, in order:
- Ideate in Midjourney or Nano Banana 2.1. Cheap, fast, and you are looking for a direction, not a deliverable.
- Produce in FLUX 3 or GPT Image 2.6. Once the direction is set, you want control and consistency.
- Fix text in Ideogram 4.0. Regenerate just the panel carrying the headline.
- Vectorise in Recraft V4.1. Anything heading for print or a UI should not stay raster.
- Clear it in Firefly if a client contract requires indemnified assets.
The cost of that stack is lower than it sounds: ideation is where volume lives, and at $0.0336 or $0.009 an image, volume is close to free. The expensive calls are the few final renders.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest AI image generator that is still good?
FLUX 3 Image Klein at $0.008 for 768×768 and $0.009 at 1K. It is 5.6 billion parameters on open weights and runs on a single consumer GPU, so you can also self-host it and pay nothing per image.
Is Nano Banana free?
Not on the API. Google lists the free tier as not available for image generation. Nano Banana 2.1 costs $0.0336 per 1K image on the paid tier. Imagen 4 Fast is $0.02.
Which AI image generator handles text in images best?
Ideogram 4.0, by a clear margin. Midjourney remains the weakest of the major models at in-image text, which is why it scores 4 out of 10 on that criterion here despite scoring 10 on output quality.
Is GPT Image 2 still current?
No. OpenAI now prices gpt-image-2.6-sunburst, gpt-image-2.6-flare, gpt-image-2.5-sunburst and gpt-image-2.5-flare. Plain gpt-image-2 appears only in the batch tier. If your code names gpt-image-2, you are on a superseded model.
Which one can I safely use for paid client work?
Adobe Firefly is the only option here with indemnification. Recraft grants commercial usage rights on every paid plan and Midjourney gives general commercial terms on all tiers, which is weaker but usually sufficient. QuillBot offers no formal licence grant.
Do unused credits expire?
On Recraft, top-up credits never expire and survive cancellation, though monthly allowances still reset. On Ideogram and Stability, credits follow the normal monthly cycle. Check before buying a large top-up anywhere else.