Who wrote this page
AIToolsRecap publishes this comparison and is one of the two sites in it. Treat it as a disclosure, not a neutral review. No winner is declared. Every figure for the other site was read off that company's own pages on 16 November 2026 and is cited at the bottom; where a figure is not published anywhere on their site, the row says so instead of guessing.
Straight answer
● The size gap is the whole story Toolify states 28,280 AIs across 459 categories. We list 1,500+ across 19. They are roughly eighteen times larger.
● What that buys each of us Their index is more likely to contain any given obscure tool. Ours carries a verdict and a dated price on every entry, which does not scale to 28,280.
● Their submission price We could not read it off their own pages on 16 November 2026 - the submit and promote pages did not return. Ask them directly.
● Free to list here Including the category placement and the review.
This is the cleanest comparison of the three because the difference is a single number. Toolify publishes 28,280 AIs across 459 categories on its home page. We publish 1,500+ across 19. Everything else about how the two sites work follows from that gap, in both directions.
Side by side
| AIToolsRecap | Toolify |
|---|
| Tools indexed | 1,500+ | 28,280, stated on their home page |
| Categories | 19 | 459, stated on their home page |
| Cost to be listed | Free, including the category placement and the review | Not published on the pages we could reach on 16 November 2026 |
| Price on each listing | Verified against the vendor page, with the date shown | Not published as a verified-and-dated figure |
| Written verdict per listing | Yes, including what the tool is bad at | Not published as a stated policy |
| Comparison pages | 300+ | Not published as a figure |
| Stated audience | Not published as a visitor figure | Not published on their home page |
| Daily editorial | Daily AI news, unbroken since 1 May 2026 | Publishes an AI news section; no cadence stated |
| Depth per entry | Verdict, dated price, comparison links | Built for breadth across 459 categories |
Eighteen times bigger is a real advantage
If you are searching for a narrow tool - a niche transcription model, a single-purpose image utility, something launched last week by one person - a 28,280-entry index is simply more likely to have it than a 1,500-entry one. 459 categories also means a finer-grained browse than 19 can offer. For pure discovery breadth, that is the better tool and there is no way to argue otherwise.
The cost of that breadth is what a directory can promise about each entry. Reading every vendor's pricing page, dating the figure and writing a verdict takes human time per listing, and that work does not multiply by eighteen. A large index is necessarily closer to an import than to a review, and that is a structural fact about size rather than a criticism of anyone's effort.
What we could not verify, and why we are saying so
Toolify's submission and promotion pages did not return when we tried to read them on 16 November 2026, so we have no submission price for them. Rather than repeat a figure from a third-party roundup, the table says not published. Every other number on this page came off a first-party page, and the ones that did not are marked rather than filled in. If you are weighing Toolify, ask them directly and get the figure in writing.
What 1,500 entries with a verdict each is actually for
Breadth answers "does a tool for this exist". Depth answers "which of these two should I pay for", and that is the question people arrive with once they already know the category. That is why 300+ comparison pages sit alongside the listings here and why each price carries the date it was checked - a pricing figure with no date on it is unverifiable by the reader, however recently it was correct.
For a founder deciding where to submit, size cuts the other way too: being one of 1,500 in 19 categories is a different kind of visibility from being one of 28,280 in 459. Neither is better in the abstract. The AI Tool Directories category lists both kinds so you can pick on something other than a domain name.
Which one you should use
You are hunting for an obscure or very new tool → Toolify. 28,280 entries across 459 categories beats 1,500 across 19 at that job.
You want the finest-grained category browse available → Toolify. 459 categories is a different product from 19.
You have narrowed it to two tools and need to choose → AIToolsRecap. 300+ comparison pages exist for precisely that moment.
You need a price you can trust without re-checking it yourself → AIToolsRecap, where every figure carries the date it was read off the vendor page.
You are a founder deciding where to submit → Here first, because it is free and takes minutes. Then ask Toolify for their price in writing, since they do not publish one we could read.
You want both → Submit to both. Breadth and depth are not competing for the same slot.
FAQ
How many AI tools does Toolify list?
28,280 across 459 categories, stated on their home page on 16 November 2026. That is roughly eighteen times our 1,500+.
How much does Toolify charge to submit a tool?
We do not know. Their submit and promote pages did not return when we tried to read them on 16 November 2026, and we will not repeat a number from a third-party roundup. Ask them directly.
Is Toolify the largest AI tool directory?
No.
There's An AI For That states 40,000+ tools on its About page, against Toolify's 28,280. What Toolify does have is the deepest category tree we have found anywhere - 459 categories - which matters more than raw count if you are browsing rather than searching.
Is a bigger directory better?
For finding an obscure tool, yes, clearly. For choosing between two tools you have already found, a verdict and a dated price matter more than the size of the index they sit in.
Is AIToolsRecap free to list on?
Yes, including the category placement and the review. Advertising and sponsor placements are paid and labelled on the page where they appear.
Why does AIToolsRecap list so few tools by comparison?
Because each entry gets a vendor-verified price with the date it was checked and a written verdict. That is human work per listing and it does not scale to 28,280. It is a deliberate trade, not a backlog.
Should I submit to both?
Yes. They do nothing to each other, and one of them is free.